It turns out, with the help of many freaked owners' articles on the internet, I've come to confirm that it was his penis! Yeah, you heard me! It's called 'fanning', and there's an explanation on this website about it as well!
So, if this happens to your turtle, don't freak out. It's normal. Luckily, his.. you know... went back inside his tail, so that means he was just putting it out for display.
Has this ever happened to any of you?




